Episode to air December 7:
- New NXT Tag Champs Johnny Gargano and Tomasso Ciampa came out and greeted the fans to a big pop, but got cut off from their promo by Paul Ellering and Authors of Pain. Ellering said they should be the tag champions, but they were interrupted by The Revival. Fans got on them for tapping out. Dawson noted they wanted a rematch, but Authors shoved Revival down. Ellering promised the next chapter will read that the Authors of Pain are NXT Tag Team Champions. Authors and Revival left, then DIY left without ever speaking.
- Alexander Wolfe and Eric Young def. No Way Jose and Rich Swann. After Jose got a hot tag, Big Damo showed up and slammed him against the ring post then left by himself, throwing a Sanity jacket on the ground.
- Ember Moon def. Queen Kimber
- Tucker Knight and Otis Dozovic def. Johnny Knockout and Braeden Knight
Episode to air December 14:
- Tye Dillinger came to the ring and announced a series of matches to determine who will meet in a Fatal Four Way to determine a new #1 Contender to the NXT Championship. Eric Young and Sanity came out for the match, which lasted about a minute. Nikki Cross interfered to give Dillinger the win by DQ. Big Damo came out again and destroyed Dillinger and left on his own.
- Andrade Almas def. No Way Jose to qualify for the Fatal Four Way
- Roderick Strong def. Elias Samson to qualify for the Fatal Four Way in about 3 minutes.
- Bobby Roode def. Oney Lorcan to qualify for the Fatal Four Way. Roode got a huge reaction.
- Peyton Royce def. Sarah Bridges (Crazy Mary Dobson). Bridges was impressive and over with the crowd.
- Shinsuke Nakamura def. Patrick Clark in a quick match
Episode to air December 21:
- Billy Kay def. Daria with some interference from Peyton Royce. Billie got booed heartily during her post-match promo.
- Authors of Pain won a squash against enhancement talents via a referee stoppage. Ellering got on the mic and said he doesn’t care who they face, DIY or the Revival, they will win the tag titles at Takeover in San Antonio.
- Bobby Roode def. Andrade Almas, Tye Dillinger, and Roderick Strong in a Fatal Four Way Elimination match to become the new #1 Contender to the NXT Championship. Order of elimination was Strong eliminating Almas, Dillinger eliminating Strong, then Roode pinning Dillinger.
- #DIY (Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa) def. The Revival to retain the NXT Tag Team Championship in a rematch from Takeover: Toronto.